“A store-bought decaf that’s consistently reliable? My top pick is Peet’s Decaf Major Dickason’s Blend ,” says Bramlett. The others agree because, as it turns out, a good decaf coffee is hard to come by. “The biggest problem with most decaf is that it tastes thin or flat,” says Morphew, explaining that this is due to the decaffeination process.

Discover how big of a difference caffeine makes.